Archives For Melky Cabrera

6900822228 e8e92ed1a4

Melky Cabrera stands on one leg. Image courtesy of flickr.

I’ve had some time to think about how valuable Melky Cabrera really is since I detailed what you can really expect from him in 2013, when he’ll (at least theoretically) be clean.

Nothing is written and stone, though, and if the Tigers take the suggestion of Dave Cameron of ESPN (insider required) and sign the Melk Man, my expectations will be significantly bolstered.

Why do I feel this way? Well, let’s take a look.

1. 2011 was a good season for Melky: In the piece linked above, I was under the assumption that Cabrera was using PED’s in 2011. When you consider what happened to him in 2012 and how much better 2011 was than his previous seasons, it may not be the worst assumption. But one thing very clearly needs to be said, in 2011, Cabrera never tested positive for anything. That’s a personal assumption based on putting a few pieces together. Take a look at what he did in 2011:

102 runs, 18 homers, 87 RBI, 20 steals, .305 average.

Had Cabrera not been suspended in 2012 and kept the same pace he was on (admittedly a lot of speculation there), this is the kind of season he would have been looking at.

116 runs, 15 homers, 83 RBI, 18 steals, .346 average.

I’m certainly not saying that the PED use didn’t aid his 2012 production, but if he was indeed clean in 2011, it’s not outlandish to say that he’s just a good hitter who improved with PED use, rather than a mediocre player who became great while using them. So, when he’s theoretically clean in 2013, you may not see him return to 2012 form, but his numbers in 2011 were pretty solid for a fantasy outfielder, considering he was above average to good in all five categories.

Ultimately, projecting 2013 depends on how much you trust what happened in 2011. But even if you think 2011 and 2012 were both dirty, there are a few other things you should consider.

2. The Detroit batting order: If he signs with Detroit, Melky will see an absurd amount of good pitches to hit because he’d be batting in front of another Cabrera, Miguel Cabrera. As the American League Triple Crown winner, Miggy is easily the most feared hitter in the game and the last thing any pitcher would want to do is face him with men on base. If you want to see how this is practically applied, I’ve got some numbers for you to see involving two of my favorite players of all-time, Rich Aurilia and Jeff Kent and how they fared hitting in front of Barry Bonds.

In 2001, Aurilia hit second for the Giants with Bonds hitting third. Hitting in front of Bonds, Aurilia got more hits than any player in the National League, coming in with a clean .324 batting average.

Early the following season, the Giants put Bonds in the four-spot, moving Kent to the three-hole. So now instead of Aurilia getting those pitches from batting in front of Bonds, it was Kent. Aurilia went from .324 to .257, drawing walks at a similar rate. Kent went from .298 in 2001 to .313 in 2002. His OBP actually remained consistent (even dropping one point) because he wasn’t drawing walks hitting in front of Bonds. You generally don’t draw walks when you’re looking at fastballs over the plate.

Batting in front of Miguel Cabrera, who just won the first Triple Crown either league had seen in 45 years, will get Melky a lot of fastballs. Quite frankly, even if you don’t trust 2011 and 2012, he’s still a much better hitter than Quintin Berry and everyone else who occupied the two-hole for Detroit this year.

With those extra fastballs, Melky would have ample chances to drive in Austin Jackson, who had a fantastic year in 2012, hitting .300, with a .379 OBP, and a .479 slugging percentage.

But obviously, the numbers don’t stop there. If Melky becomes a Tiger, he’ll have a decent chance of scoring a run every time he reaches base, with Miggy and Prince Fielder hitting in the next two slots. He had that to an extent in 2012 batting in front of Buster Posey, but even Posey isn’t as powerful as Miggy or Prince, and a lot of Posey’s great 2012 play came after Melky’s suspension. Posey had 10 homers with a .289 average in the first half against 14 homers and a .385 average after the break, despite fewer games and at-bats.

It doesn’t stop there.

3. Melky will have a lot to prove in 2013: This one is pretty self-explanatory. If the Tigers take Cameron’s suggestion, Melky will be signed to a one-year contract and quite frankly, it’s hard to see anyone committing any more than one year to him.

If you look at his numbers before 2011, Melky had a .267 career average, .328 OBP, and .379 slugging percentage. Not exactly brilliant production.

If he has a poor year in 2013, this is what teams will be looking at next offseason: A mediocre hitting 29-year-old who will turn 30 during the 2014 season with a PED past. Remember, another positive test is a 100-game suspension.

But with a strong year in 2013, it’s not hard to imagine Melky getting a nice 3-5 year contract worth close to $10 million a year next offseason. After all, he would have shown that while 2012 was certainly PED aided, he can in fact hit. Teams are quite forgiving of player’s disgretions if they produce. With another good year in 2013, he would cash in on a big contract. With a bad 2013, he may not even be a starting outfielder on Opening Day 2014. It’s really that simple.

There’s one other thing to consider on that end. The Giants clearly didn’t get hurt by Melky’s absence in 2012. As a matter of fact, they really rallied around his suspension, running away with the NL West (the race was very close when he was suspended on August 15) and eventually winning the World Series. He’ll be motivated to prove that he can make a big impact on a contender. I’m not saying he didn’t help the Giants in 2012, but their late-season and postseason success did not help his value at all.

Ultimately, a lot can happen with Melky in 2013 and a lot does depend on his situation. He’ll have a lot to prove next year, but needs to be in a good situation to be a productive fantasy player. Batting in front of a Triple Crown winner who himself is protected by a banger like Prince would be the ideal situation.

 

Cabrera’s 2013 Projection Range in Detroit


AB H R HR RBI SB AVG 
Best Case Scenario  660 218 119 19 85 12 .330
Worst Case Scenario  540 139 79 8 43 9 .257
Actual Projections 605 180 102 14 79 15 .298

Guest Spot on the Dear Mr. Fantasy Podcast

Clave Jones —  August 20, 2012 — 4 Comments

Chris McBrien of the Dear Mr. Fantasy Podcast was kind enough to invite me to be this week’s guest on his show. As always, Chris was joined by the Fantasy Doctor and we discussed all things fantasy baseball. Plus, we picked our favorite Spice Girl.

Fantasy baseball news included Melky Cabrera (SF) suspension, the Justin Smoak (SEA) recall, an Alex Rodriguez (NYY) injury update and Roberto Hernandez (CLE) return to major league baseball.

We discussed hot players (‘Hot’ being relative to on-the-field performance and not physical attractiveness) : Todd Frazier (CIN), Eric Young (COL) and Rajai Davis ( TOR) . We also discussed cold players, Brian McCann (ATL) and Trevor Plouffe (MIN).

Some quality pitchers are on the waiver wire: Jeremy Guthrie (KC), Kris Medlen (ATL) and Lucas Harrell (HOU). We discussed if they are legit and worth an add.

We also responded to emails from listeners.

It was a good time and I appreciate the invite. The guys do a quality podcast week in and week out. I highly encourage you to head over to iTunes and subscribe. Coming in at under an hour, you gets lots of relevant fantasy baseball information and you’ll be entertained as well.

For me, it’s always been hard to not root for the Kansas City Royals. I wanted them to win, if just because. Of course, it’s been hard to root for the Royals because they never win…well, because. So even though they are riddled with young talent you are never really confident that they’ll even remember how to win. But let’s focus on the talent and hope for the best, shall we?

Wil Myers has been tearing up minor league pitching across 2 levels this year to the tune of 21 home runs and a .325+ AVG thus far. He’s striking out over 20% of his ABs, but he’s also carried a walk rate above 10% at most stops and he’s considered to have great plate discipline and the ability to hit the ball anywhere in the zone (Like Britney Spears, you gotta keep it in the zone). You can watch his BP here.

But he’s a catcher converted to right field, meaning there is no place for him to play, particularly with the imminent return of Lorenzo Cain. Plus, with rumors saying that in order to make room for Billy Butler at 1B, Hosmer might play a little in left field during inter league play, making the outfield really crowded.

(SIDE NOTE: Houston will be moving to the American League next year, giving each league an odd number of teams. This means that at any given time we’ll have at least one inter league series, upping the number of times that teams try position change experiments to get their DH into the lineup, at least in NL parks. It’s fun to think of what positional eligibility changes this will bring in fantasy baseball next year.)

Even though he seems to be forcing the hand of the Royals, you sometimes just never know if they end up getting the call, particularly in a situation like this where the outfield is crowded. But what is it that the GMs like to say when questioned about logjams and timetables? “These things have a way of working themselves out.”

Trading Jeff Francoeur is the obvious choice, but with that guy buying everyone pizza, it’ll be hard to see a fan favorite go, even if they could use the pitching help (Sorry, one more SIDE NOTE: Remember when the Royals – the team that led the MLB in walks issued – traded Melky Cabrera for Jonathan Sanchez, a pitcher who can’t throw the ball over the plate? Good times.)

You look at Myers’ scouting reports (here and here) and you realize that he needs to get called up, sooner rather than later. In terms of fantasy baseball, I would absolutely grab him if you have a bench spot, if just with the HR boost that you’ll get from him.

FINAL SIDE NOTE: I want to leave you with a little homework. Familiarize yourself with the scouting report on Bubba Starling, and follow him closely. It will give you a head start on the his call up report in 2014. He’ll be another monster for the Royals.

Bronson  Arroyo 02

Welcome back to Dixon’s Picks. Before we get going, I want to wish a Happy Memorial Day to everyone out there. It’s certainly a day to have fun, but take some time to remember what we’re honoring today. I actually got to spend some time last week with some old friends, who are both in the Armed Forces. I am certainly not ashamed to say that these are two of my heroes. They deserve all the praise in the world every day, but certainly today is a day to be thankful to those who serve and have served, whether they’re still with us or not.

Anyway, baseball on Memorial Day is a great tradition. Since it features a lot of unusual Monday day games, most of you guys are probably in a hurry to make some moves for the day, so let’s get to it.

 

Scott Diamond – Minnesota Twins

Projected Starts: Monday vs. Oakland. Sunday at Cleveland

Right off the bat, I should clarify that I am not telling anyone to stream against the Indians. They are a pretty good offense, notably when it comes to getting on base. The purpose of having Dixon’s Picks on Monday, however, is for the benefit of people in weekly league. In roto leagues, one week to the other makes no difference.

So, those in weekly leagues should pick Scott Diamond up for Monday’s start and see how things are looking on Sunday. If you’re in need of some counted stats and aren’t concerned with WHIP and ERA, put Diamond in the lineup on Sunday. If you don’t want to gamble, then don’t.

But while I am not recommending you start him against the Indians, it’s not the worst of ideas. After all, in four starts this year, Diamond has gone against the Angels, Blue Jays, Brewers, and White Sox. While he gives up hits, walks are rare, and the run totals have been respectable. The only time he’s thrown and it wasn’t a quality start was against the Brewers, where he went 5 1/3 and allowed three earned. Not a quality start, but hardly getting shelled.

The A’s are a good offense to stream against at all times. You can decide what to do against the Indians based on your own team, but I am certainly not expecting a terrible outing.

Diamond’s Projections for the week

    IP         H         BB         ER          W           K         ERA        WHIP    
    14    14      2      4       1     11     3.21     1.14

 

Bronson Arroyo – Cincinnati Reds

Projected Starts: Monday at Pittsburgh. Sunday at Houston

Just as a quick note, I stream a lot of players every week. In our head to head league, I rarely ever lose strikeouts, because I stream so often. Now, my K’s per nine innings totals are never high, but that doesn’t matter. If I throw two guys who have a seven-inning, four strikeout game, that’s eight strikeouts, albeit not with a great average. If someone throws one starter who throws seven innings with seven strikeouts, his guy had the better start, but extrapolating that out, my guys will have the better week in that category.

The risk comes with stats like WHIP, which is why I look for low walk guys, which perfectly describes Bronson Arroyo. He enters the week with 58 2/3 innings thrown and 66 hits, not good. But by the same token, Arroyo has only eight walks, leading to a cool WHIP of 1.26. No, that won’t lead the league, but for a guy available in almost 95 percent of leagues, it’s not bad at all.

Arroyo is an especially nice play this week as the Pirates and Astros are both in the bottom-third in most major offensive categories. If you don’t beat yourself with the walk against these teams, you are going to have a good day. Again, I will repeat, eight walks in nine starts. If you don’t like those odds, something’s wrong with you.

He’ll be around the plate against two unimposing offenses. In all, there is nothing that I don’t like about this play.

Arroyo’s Projections for the week

    IP         H         BB         ER          W           K         ERA        WHIP    
    15    14      1      4      2     10     2.40     1.00

 

Jeff Suppan – San Diego Padres. Travis Wood – Chicago Cubs

Projected Starts: Monday vs. each other in Chicago

Both of these guys do go twice this week, but Sunday’s matchups aren’t great. Jeff Suppan will be at home against the Diamondbacks, while Travis Wood will be in San Francisco. Wood is probably the better play there, but I wouldn’t suggest either.

But I am always looking for guys going twice. Taking both starting pitchers when two of the worst offenses in the league are going against each other works for me. As it happens, these pitchers are both available in more than 99 percent of leagues. Obviously, you won’t get two wins, but the other numbers will be quite nice for you.

I look at these offenses, and I don’t see much happening. Wood has been good thus far and Suppan’s struggles have been against far better offenses than the Cubs. Again, you won’t get two wins from one game, but you will be off to a good start in nearly all other statistics.

Suppan and Wood’s Combined Projections for the week

    IP         H         BB         ER          W           K         ERA        WHIP    
    13    11      5      4       1      9     2.77     1.23

 

Joaquin Arias – Infielder, San Francisco Giants

Week’s Schedule: 3 vs. AZ, 3 vs. CHC

Arias has a few things working well for him here. For one, he’s swinging too good of a bat for the Giants to even consider benching him. The top of the order guys in San Francisco get on base well, but beyond the five spot, their offense takes a big drop, if Arias is riding the pine, that is. He should not ride the pine for that reason and also, reason number two, his swing is custom built for the gaps of AT&T Park, which is where he will be for all six games this week.

The way that guys like Melky Cabrera, Angel Pagan, and Buster Posey have been swinging, Joaquin Arias will have plenty of chances to drive runs in. He is swinging a good bat right now, hitting a lot of line drives. With men on base, those will produce runs.

Lastly, what works for Arias is that he has eligibility at second, third, and short, which aren’t the deepest of positions. He reached base in every game last week, even hitting one over the fence. While I am not normally big on average over one week, note that Arias went 0-for-3 on Sunday (drawing a walk to reach base), and still hit .345. Over a week, if you have a guy who goes 0-for-3 one day and still hits at a strong clip that week, it’s a sign that he’s seeing the ball well.

Look for good things to continue, especially against two teams that are near or in the bottom-third of most major pitching pitching categories.

Arias’ Projections for the week

    H         AB          R         HR          RBI           SB         AVG     
    7     24      3      1        5       1     .292

Shake n’ Bake

Clave Jones —  December 1, 2011 — Leave a comment

         

One of our fantasy baseball league mates is Steve Gansen. He’s crazy smart and has an obscene amount of trivial information about old school baseball players locked in his brain. Once a month he posts a comparison of one of today’s players with a player from yesteryear in our league message boards. We’ve given him the title of “League Historian.” Below is one such comparison:

As our league historian in charge of monthly comparisons of one of today’s stars with one from yesteryear, I offer my first such comparison:

Yesteryear
Bake McBride, Phillies/Cardinals/Indians 1973-1983

162 Game Average:
PA  AB  R   H  2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO AVE OBP SLG OPS
636 583 83 174 25   8    10    65    28  10   38  69  .299   .345  .420 .765

Today’s Player
Melky Cabrera, Yankees/Braves/Royals 2005-2011

162 Game Average:
PA  AB  R   H  2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO AVE OBP SLG OPS
625 565 75 155 30   4      11   66     13    5   46  75   .275   .331  .398 .729

Yes, Bake and Melky’s offensive stats have striking similarities. I also considered Sixto Lezcano as the player from yesteryear with similar stats to Melky’s, but Bake wins out in this funny name comparison because he had the nickname “Shake n’ Bake,” but most importantly, because he had the Princess Leia hairdo.